Best garage door companies in New Berlin, WI

The highest-scoring garage door company in and near New Berlin is Anytime Garage Doors (score 84, 4.9 stars from 873 Google reviews). 17 companies meet the 5 Star standard within about 16 miles.

Last updated Nov 1, 2026How we rank
  1. 1

    Anytime Garage Doors

    4.9 · 873 Google reviewsSussex, WI31 years in business

    Anytime Garage Doors installs, repairs, and maintains residential and commercial garage doors in Sussex and surrounding Wisconsin communities. Family-owned and operated since 1995, the company serves Waukesha County a…

    Emergency service
    84SCORE
  2. 2

    Balkan Door Company LLC

    5.0 · 501 Google reviewsSt Francis, WI

    Balkan Door Company LLC is a family-owned and operated garage door service company serving Milwaukee, Southeast Wisconsin, and surrounding communities. It handles residential and commercial garage doors, including rep…

    80SCORE
  3. 3

    A1 Garage Door Service

    4.8 · 6,091 Google reviewsWest Allis, WI
    78SCORE
  4. 4

    Joe Wilde Company

    5.0 · 491 Google reviewsNew Berlin, WI
    77SCORE
  5. 5

    Precision Overhead Garage Door

    4.8 · 1,366 Google reviewsMenomonee Falls, WI
    75SCORE
  6. 6

    O'Brien Garage Doors

    4.9 · 440 Google reviews
    75SCORE
  7. 7

    Garage Door Professional LLC

    4.9 · 230 Google reviewsBrookfield, WI
    74SCORE
  8. 8

    DiamondLift

    5.0 · 77 Google reviews
    73SCORE
  9. 9
    71SCORE
  10. 10

    Lifetime Door Company, Inc.

    4.8 · 355 Google reviewsBrookfield, WI
    66SCORE
  11. 11

    Overhead Door Company of Southeast Wisconsin

    4.8 · 90 Google reviewsCudahy, WI
    64SCORE
  12. 12

    Hung Right Garage Doors, LLC

    5.0 · 37 Google reviews
    64SCORE
  13. 13

    Ultimate Cudahy Doors & Gates

    4.7 · 75 Google reviewsCudahy, WI
    63SCORE
  14. 14

    Owen's Doors & Gates

    4.8 · 42 Google reviewsMenomonee Falls, WI
    63SCORE
  15. 15

    A.N.D Garage Door Service

    5.0 · 164 Google reviews
    62SCORE
  16. 16

    Blando Door Co LLC

    5.0 · 47 Google reviewsWaukesha, WI
    62SCORE
  17. 17

    All Garage Door Repair LLC

    5.0 · 34 Google reviews
    60SCORE

We list only companies that clear our published bar, so this area is still filling in. As more garage door companies near New Berlin qualify, they'll appear here automatically.

Compare the top 10

Top garage door companies in New Berlin by 5 Star Score
#CompanyScoreGoogle ratingReviewsYearsBased in
1Anytime Garage Doors844.987331Sussex
2Balkan Door Company LLC805.0501–St Francis
3A1 Garage Door Service784.86,091–West Allis
4Joe Wilde Company775.0491–New Berlin
5Precision Overhead Garage Door754.81,366–Menomonee Falls
6O'Brien Garage Doors754.9440–
7Garage Door Professional LLC744.9230–Brookfield
8DiamondLift735.077–
9In&Out Residential Garage Door Service LLC715.0114–
10Lifetime Door Company, Inc.664.8355–Brookfield

Garage door companies in New Berlin: quick answers

Who is the highest-rated garage door company in New Berlin, WI?

Anytime Garage Doors has the highest 5 Star Score among garage door companies in and near New Berlin: 84 out of 100, with a 4.9 star Google rating from 873 reviews.

How many 5 Star garage door companies serve New Berlin?

17 garage door companies meet our standard within about 16 miles of New Berlin: at least a 4.5 star rating, 20 or more reviews and a score of 60 or higher. The top 17 have 11,027 Google reviews between them, averaging 4.91 stars.

How are these garage door companies ranked?

By 5 Star Score: rating quality adjusted for review count (45 points), review volume (25), review recency (15), years in business (10) and license verification (5). Businesses cannot pay to change their score.

Other pros in New Berlin

Search another area

Try a zip code, a nearby city, or a state.

Ratings and review counts come from each company's public Google listing and are re-checked monthly. 5 Star Home Service Pros is independent; companies cannot pay for placement.