Best roofers in Carmel, IN

The highest-scoring roofer in and near Carmel is Amos Exteriors (score 90, 4.9 stars from 3,309 Google reviews). 50 companies meet the 5 Star standard within about 16 miles; the top 30 are ranked below.

Last updated Nov 1, 2026How we rank
  1. 1

    Amos Exteriors

    4.9 · 3,309 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN55 years in business

    Amos Exteriors is a family-owned and operated exterior remodeling company serving homeowners and businesses across Central Indiana since 1971. Its residential and commercial services include roof repair and replacemen…

    Financing availableEmergency service
    90SCORE
  2. 2

    Indy Rooftops

    5.0 · 588 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN

    Indy Rooftops is a family-owned, woman-owned roofing and exterior company serving Indianapolis and surrounding communities. It handles roof repairs, roof replacement, storm damage restoration, emergency tarping, roof…

    Emergency service
    82SCORE
  3. 3

    Weathertight Roofing

    5.0 · 345 Google reviewsFishers, IN
    80SCORE
  4. 4

    OpenBox Roofing

    5.0 · 280 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    79SCORE
  5. 5

    RoofCo

    5.0 · 260 Google reviewsBrownsburg, IN
    79SCORE
  6. 6

    Bone Dry Roofing

    4.8 · 2,491 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    78SCORE
  7. 7

    Big Boy's Construction

    4.9 · 897 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    78SCORE
  8. 8

    3 Kings Roofing and Construction

    5.0 · 196 Google reviewsFishers, IN
    76SCORE
  9. 9

    Stay Dry Roofing

    4.9 · 447 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    75SCORE
  10. 10

    Red Bird Roofing

    4.9 · 292 Google reviewsCarmel, IN
    75SCORE
  11. 11

    Beard Roofing and Exteriors

    4.9 · 261 Google reviewsCarmel, IN
    75SCORE
  12. 12

    The Roof Squad

    4.9 · 257 Google reviewsCarmel, IN
    75SCORE
  13. 13

    Mister Quik Home Services

    4.7 · 8,822 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    74SCORE
  14. 14

    Jax Roofing Company

    4.9 · 192 Google reviewsCarmel, IN
    74SCORE
  15. 15

    Element Roofing

    4.9 · 189 Google reviewsCarmel, IN
    73SCORE
  16. 16

    Ultra Dry Roofing

    4.9 · 131 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    73SCORE
  17. 17

    Blue Ladder Roofing

    4.8 · 419 Google reviewsFishers, IN
    72SCORE
  18. 18

    Watergate Roofing

    5.0 · 200 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    72SCORE
  19. 19

    Kingdom Roofing Systems

    4.9 · 105 Google reviewsFishers, IN
    72SCORE
  20. 20

    Strenova Exteriors

    5.0 · 100 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    72SCORE
  21. 21

    The Hammer Construction & Consulting

    4.9 · 100 Google reviews
    71SCORE
  22. 22

    Porter Roofing & Restoration

    4.8 · 255 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    70SCORE
  23. 23

    Locke & Ladder

    5.0 · 186 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    70SCORE
  24. 24

    Cox Roofing

    4.8 · 529 Google reviewsZionsville, IN
    69SCORE
  25. 25

    Myers Exteriors

    5.0 · 139 Google reviewsCarmel, IN
    69SCORE
  26. 26

    ARAC Roof It Forward

    4.7 · 337 Google reviewsNoblesville, IN
    68SCORE
  27. 27

    Two Brothers Roofing Inc

    4.9 · 108 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    68SCORE
  28. 28

    Single Play Restoration Services LLC

    5.0 · 84 Google reviewsIndianapolis, IN
    68SCORE
  29. 29

    Mattox Roofing & Restoration

    4.9 · 103 Google reviews
    67SCORE
  30. 30

    Indy Legacy Builders Roofing

    5.0 · 66 Google reviewsFishers, IN
    67SCORE

Compare the top 10

Top roofers in Carmel by 5 Star Score
#CompanyScoreGoogle ratingReviewsYearsBased in
1Amos Exteriors904.93,30955Indianapolis
2Indy Rooftops825.0588–Indianapolis
3Weathertight Roofing805.0345–Fishers
4OpenBox Roofing795.0280–Indianapolis
5RoofCo795.0260–Brownsburg
6Bone Dry Roofing784.82,491–Indianapolis
7Big Boy's Construction784.9897–Indianapolis
83 Kings Roofing and Construction765.0196–Fishers
9Stay Dry Roofing754.9447–Indianapolis
10Red Bird Roofing754.9292–Carmel

Roofers in Carmel: quick answers

Who is the highest-rated roofer in Carmel, IN?

Amos Exteriors has the highest 5 Star Score among roofers in and near Carmel: 90 out of 100, with a 4.9 star Google rating from 3,309 reviews.

How many 5 Star roofers serve Carmel?

50 roofers meet our standard within about 16 miles of Carmel: at least a 4.5 star rating, 20 or more reviews and a score of 60 or higher. The top 30 have 21,688 Google reviews between them, averaging 4.91 stars.

How are these roofers ranked?

By 5 Star Score: rating quality adjusted for review count (45 points), review volume (25), review recency (15), years in business (10) and license verification (5). Businesses cannot pay to change their score.

Other pros in Carmel

Search another area

Try a zip code, a nearby city, or a state.

Ratings and review counts come from each company's public Google listing and are re-checked monthly. 5 Star Home Service Pros is independent; companies cannot pay for placement.