Best roofers in Caledonia, WI

The highest-scoring roofer in and near Caledonia is Window Depot USA of Milwaukee St. Francis Main Office & Showroom (score 83, 4.9 stars from 4,394 Google reviews). 14 companies meet the 5 Star standard within about 16 miles.

Last updated Nov 1, 2026How we rank
  1. 1

    Window Depot USA of Milwaukee St. Francis Main Office & Showroom

    4.9 · 4,394 Google reviewsSt Francis, WI

    Window Depot USA of Milwaukee | St. Francis Main Office & Showroom provides replacement windows, entry doors, vinyl siding, bathroom makeovers, and residential roofing for Greater Milwaukee homeowners. The company off…

    83SCORE
  2. 2

    Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal Company

    5.0 · 297 Google reviewsNew Berlin, WI
    79SCORE
  3. 3

    All Season Roofing

    5.0 · 403 Google reviewsGreendale, WI
    78SCORE
  4. 4

    Absolute Home Improvements Inc.

    5.0 · 279 Google reviewsFranklin, WI
    78SCORE
  5. 5

    J&J Contractors I LLC

    4.9 · 592 Google reviewsGreendale, WI
    77SCORE
  6. 6

    Modern Exterior Roofing

    4.9 · 399 Google reviewsWest Allis, WI
    76SCORE
  7. 7

    Knight Plumbing & Drain Cleaning

    4.8 · 1,141 Google reviewsMilwaukee, WI
    74SCORE
  8. 8

    Feldco Windows, Siding, Doors & Roofing of Milwaukee

    4.7 · 1,064 Google reviewsMilwaukee, WI
    71SCORE
  9. 9

    Leap Frog Roofing

    5.0 · 70 Google reviewsCudahy, WI
    71SCORE
  10. 10

    Zam Zam Roofing

    4.9 · 128 Google reviewsOak Creek, WI
    68SCORE
  11. 11

    Good Home Improvement LLC

    5.0 · 44 Google reviews
    67SCORE
  12. 12

    Redtail Roofing LLC

    5.0 · 32 Google reviewsCudahy, WI
    63SCORE
  13. 13

    W. Forrest Roofing & Sheet Metal LLC

    5.0 · 24 Google reviews
    63SCORE
  14. 14

    Absolute Restorations

    5.0 · 89 Google reviewsMilwaukee, WI
    61SCORE

We list only companies that clear our published bar, so this area is still filling in. As more roofers near Caledonia qualify, they'll appear here automatically.

Compare the top 10

Top roofers in Caledonia by 5 Star Score
#CompanyScoreGoogle ratingReviewsYearsBased in
1Window Depot USA of Milwaukee St. Francis Main Office & Showroom834.94,394–St Francis
2Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal Company795.0297–New Berlin
3All Season Roofing785.0403–Greendale
4Absolute Home Improvements Inc.785.0279–Franklin
5J&J Contractors I LLC774.9592–Greendale
6Modern Exterior Roofing764.9399–West Allis
7Knight Plumbing & Drain Cleaning744.81,141–Milwaukee
8Feldco Windows, Siding, Doors & Roofing of Milwaukee714.71,064–Milwaukee
9Leap Frog Roofing715.070–Cudahy
10Zam Zam Roofing684.9128–Oak Creek

Roofers in Caledonia: quick answers

Who is the highest-rated roofer in Caledonia, WI?

Window Depot USA of Milwaukee St. Francis Main Office & Showroom has the highest 5 Star Score among roofers in and near Caledonia: 83 out of 100, with a 4.9 star Google rating from 4,394 reviews.

How many 5 Star roofers serve Caledonia?

14 roofers meet our standard within about 16 miles of Caledonia: at least a 4.5 star rating, 20 or more reviews and a score of 60 or higher. The top 14 have 8,956 Google reviews between them, averaging 4.94 stars.

How are these roofers ranked?

By 5 Star Score: rating quality adjusted for review count (45 points), review volume (25), review recency (15), years in business (10) and license verification (5). Businesses cannot pay to change their score.

Other pros in Caledonia

Search another area

Try a zip code, a nearby city, or a state.

Ratings and review counts come from each company's public Google listing and are re-checked monthly. 5 Star Home Service Pros is independent; companies cannot pay for placement.