5 Star Home Service Pros
Claim your profileList my Business

Best roofers in Menomonee Falls, WI

The highest-scoring roofer in and near Menomonee Falls is Billy Goat Roofing (score 80, 5.0 stars from 334 Google reviews). 46 companies meet the 5 Star standard within 25 km; the top 30 are ranked below.

Last updated Sep 25, 2026How we rank
  1. 1

    Billy Goat Roofing

    5.0 · 334 Google reviews
    80SCORE
    (414) 426-7885 WebsiteFull profile
  2. 2

    Tri-County Contracting

    4.9 · 800 Google reviewsNew Berlin, WI
    79SCORE
    (262) 287-9871 WebsiteFull profile
  3. 3

    Infinity Exteriors

    4.8 · 2,505 Google reviewsNew Berlin, WI
    78SCORE
    (262) 747-2149 WebsiteFull profile
  4. 4

    WeatherPro Exteriors

    4.9 · 676 Google reviewsWest Allis, WI
    78SCORE
    (262) 698-3227 WebsiteFull profile
  5. 5

    Peak and Valley Roofing Company

    5.0 · 221 Google reviewsMequon, WI
    78SCORE
    (414) 207-6107 WebsiteFull profile
  6. 6

    Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal Company

    5.0 · 288 Google reviewsNew Berlin, WI
    77SCORE
    (414) 529-9549 WebsiteFull profile
  7. 7

    Modern Exterior Roofing

    4.9 · 377 Google reviewsWest Allis, WI
    76SCORE
    (262) 240-6454 WebsiteFull profile
  8. 8

    Ridge Top Exteriors

    4.8 · 1,043 Google reviewsWauwatosa, WI
    75SCORE
    (414) 244-9416 WebsiteFull profile
  9. 9

    JRV Exteriors

    4.9 · 237 Google reviewsMilwaukee, WI
    74SCORE
    (414) 331-7849 WebsiteFull profile
  10. 10

    Vault Roofing

    4.9 · 190 Google reviewsWauwatosa, WI
    74SCORE
    (414) 301-2983 WebsiteFull profile
  11. 11

    Knight Plumbing & Drain Cleaning

    5.0 · 120 Google reviewsMilwaukee, WI
    74SCORE
    (414) 677-8301 WebsiteFull profile
  12. 12

    Milwaukee Roofing

    4.9 · 311 Google reviewsBrown Deer, WI
    73SCORE
    (414) 533-7569 WebsiteFull profile
  13. 13

    Guardian Home Improvements

    4.8 · 508 Google reviewsNew Berlin, WI
    72SCORE
    (414) 226-5619 WebsiteFull profile
  14. 14

    Bulldog Builders

    4.8 · 365 Google reviewsWaukesha, WI
    72SCORE
    (262) 933-8777 WebsiteFull profile
  15. 15

    Community Roofing & Restoration

    4.8 · 332 Google reviewsMilwaukee, WI
    72SCORE
    (414) 206-1678 WebsiteFull profile
  16. 16

    Standard Roofing & Restoration

    4.9 · 267 Google reviewsWauwatosa, WI
    72SCORE
    (262) 212-5853 WebsiteFull profile
  17. 17

    Great Lakes Roofing Corporation

    4.9 · 133 Google reviewsGermantown, WI
    72SCORE
    (262) 253-9550 WebsiteFull profile
  18. 18

    Expert Exteriors

    5.0 · 79 Google reviewsMenomonee Falls, WI
    72SCORE
    (414) 519-1260 WebsiteFull profile
  19. 19

    Hucke Exteriors, Inc.

    4.9 · 132 Google reviewsBrookfield, WI
    70SCORE
    (262) 747-2424 WebsiteFull profile
  20. 20

    L. H. Krueger and Son, Inc.

    4.8 · 250 Google reviewsWaukesha, WI
    69SCORE
    (262) 547-5054 WebsiteFull profile
  21. 21

    Milwaukee Roof repairs

    5.0 · 106 Google reviewsWest Allis, WI
    69SCORE
    (414) 800-2650Full profile
  22. 22

    New Roofs Inc.

    5.0 · 153 Google reviewsWaukesha, WI
    68SCORE
    (262) 232-8004 WebsiteFull profile
  23. 23

    A & A Exteriors LLC

    5.0 · 84 Google reviewsMilwaukee, WI
    68SCORE
    (414) 416-5038 WebsiteFull profile
  24. 24

    Cornerstone Roofing, Inc.

    5.0 · 66 Google reviews
    68SCORE
    (262) 323-3223 WebsiteFull profile
  25. 25

    Wisconsin Roofing, LLC

    4.9 · 178 Google reviewsRichfield, WI
    67SCORE
    (262) 349-6338 WebsiteFull profile
  26. 26

    Four Leaf Roofing & Windows

    4.9 · 160 Google reviewsNew Berlin, WI
    67SCORE
    (414) 455-2345 WebsiteFull profile
  27. 27

    Elite Exteriors LLC

    4.8 · 144 Google reviewsNew Berlin, WI
    67SCORE
    (262) 641-5760 WebsiteFull profile
  28. 28

    Weather Tight Corporation

    4.7 · 877 Google reviewsWest Allis, WI
    66SCORE
    (414) 459-3874 WebsiteFull profile
  29. 29

    Evansen Builders, LLC

    5.0 · 88 Google reviewsNew Berlin, WI
    66SCORE
    (262) 549-9700 WebsiteFull profile
  30. 30

    Extra Mile Exteriors

    4.9 · 46 Google reviews
    66SCORE
    (414) 801-0996 WebsiteFull profile

We list only companies that clear our published bar, so this area is still filling in. As more roofers near Menomonee Falls qualify, they'll appear here automatically.

Compare the top 10

Top roofers in Menomonee Falls by 5 Star Score
#CompanyScoreGoogle ratingReviewsYearsBased in
1Billy Goat Roofing805.0334–
2Tri-County Contracting794.9800–New Berlin
3Infinity Exteriors784.82,505–New Berlin
4WeatherPro Exteriors784.9676–West Allis
5Peak and Valley Roofing Company785.0221–Mequon
6Smart Roofing & Sheet Metal Company775.0288–New Berlin
7Modern Exterior Roofing764.9377–West Allis
8Ridge Top Exteriors754.81,043–Wauwatosa
9JRV Exteriors744.9237–Milwaukee
10Vault Roofing744.9190–Wauwatosa

Roofers in Menomonee Falls: quick answers

Who is the highest-rated roofer in Menomonee Falls, WI?

Billy Goat Roofing has the highest 5 Star Score among roofers in and near Menomonee Falls: 80 out of 100, with a 5.0 star Google rating from 334 reviews.

How many 5 Star roofers serve Menomonee Falls?

46 roofers meet our standard within 25 km of Menomonee Falls: at least a 4.5 star rating, 20 or more reviews and a score of 60 or higher. The top 30 have 11,070 Google reviews between them, averaging 4.90 stars.

How are these roofers ranked?

By 5 Star Score: rating quality adjusted for review count (45 points), review volume (25), review recency (15), years in business (10) and license verification (5). Businesses cannot pay to change their score.

Roofers near Menomonee Falls

Other pros in Menomonee Falls

Search another area

Try a zip code, a nearby city, or a state.

Ratings and review counts come from each company's public Google listing and are re-checked monthly. 5 Star Home Service Pros is independent; companies cannot pay for placement.